» Young Guns (Special Edition)

Young Guns (Special Edition) Reviews

Customer Rating:
Summary: Great Service
Comment: The seller shipped fast and the item was exactly in the condition as promised. Good work.

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: Horrible blu-ray transfer. Worst in my collection. Terrible jaggies.
Comment: This is a review of the blu-ray transfer. It is just terrible. It's the worst in my collection of over 140 discs. There is stairstepping on everything. It's just awful. I don't know why Amazon insists on sticking reviews of DVD in with the blu-ray reviews.

I just want to warn people that this is not worth an upgrade. There was some sort of serious error in the conversion process. I wish I could get my money back!

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: Great Movie
Comment: One of the great old west movies. Love history about the old west or Billy the kid this movie says it all...great quality

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: bad story, bad acting, bad western
Comment: this was made when the actors were all young and still trying to learn their trade. they had not. i do not know who wrote the story, but he ought not to lose his day job. all those who took part ought to learn about the genre, because they missed the whole point

do not buy this movie unless you like to spend almost two hours looking at nice horses and trying to ignore what is happening around them.

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: An Entertaining Movie In More Ways Than One: Truth, History, And Legend
Comment: This review is for "Young Guns (Special Edition)" DVD
(Widescreen; "The Real Billy the Kid" Documentary; Trivia Track--"Gunning for the 'Fact';" and Audio Commentary with Lou Diamond Phillips, Dermot Mulroney and Casey Siemoszko)

I am unsure which was more entertaining: the movie "Young Guns;" the trivia track for the movie; or the so called documentary, "The Real Billy the Kid." This is because the one thing that can be said about the historical Billy the Kid is that the "facts" are essentially unverifiable; which has lead to a division of sorts between "historians" writing about Billy the Kid. In all of my own secondary research, I have concluded that Robert Utley's book, "Billy the Kid: A Short and Violent Life," is the most valid interpretation.

Given that "Young Guns" was intended to be a movie loaded with "stars and future stars," more than anything else, the movie clearly demonstrates what great actors can do if they are willing to go the distance ("Young Guns" was shot in only six weeks). Moreover, I--and I am going out on a limb here, as I have not researched this--am of the mind that the movie was also intended to tell the story of the "legend" of Billy the Kid as a metaphor for current popular culture; including the "non-traditional" soundtrack. (However, also see Sam Peckinpah's "Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid" for a "non-traditional soundtrack and more violent interpretation of Billy the Kid). Regardless, I cannot say enough about just how exciting and energetic "Young Guns" is to watch. The "young stars," even the small cameos, all add to the film.

As for the "documentary," I almost split a gut laughing. I am not sure if the "documentary" was intended to present the "truth" about Billy the Kid, but that was not the case, except perhaps from some radical perspective, although some "facts"--and again, all "facts" about Billy the Kid are subject to change--were informative.

The trivia track was a hoot. Again, I must believe that much of the "trivia" was done with tongue in cheek. Whatever the reason, the "trivia" sure made the movie, "Young Guns," all the more fun to watch.

In the final analysis, it is my true belief that "Young Guns" should be--if not already--considered a classical western.

Lastly, for those who want to "quickly" learn (instead of reading Robert Utley's book) about the questionable history of Billy the Kid, go to the Wikipedia site. Or one can watch "Gore Vidal's Billy the Kid" (1989--a year after "Young Guns"), starring Val Kilmer as Billy and Duncan Regehr as Pat Garrett. While this movie is currently available only in VHS format, it is also filmed like a more "traditional western;" but, in my opinion is the most "historically accurate" movie about Billy the Kid.

Update--1 July 2008: If this review was not helpful to you, I would appreciate learning the reason(s) so I can improve my reviews. My goal is to provide help to potential buyers, not get into any arguments. So, if you only disagree with my opinion, could you please say so in the comments and not indicate that the review was not helpful. Thanks.

---

More Reviews for Young Guns (Special Edition)